Eggnog Pumpkin Pie
If you’re looking for something new for your holiday dessert table, this Eggnog Pumpkin Pie brings together two seasonal favorites in one delicious treat. A warmly spiced pumpkin-eggnog custard bakes up rich and creamy in a flaky pastry crust, while a buttery pecan streusel adds a crisp, crumbly contrast. Cinnamon and nutmeg tie everything together for a festive twist on classic pumpkin pie.

Pumpkin pie is one of my husband’s absolute favorite pies, so I make sure there is a pumpkin pie on the table for both Thanksgiving and Christmas. Early on in our marriage, I would make my Caramel Toffee Pumpkin Pie for both. But with barely a month between Thanksgiving and Christmas, I’m generally not ready to serve the same pie twice. So, many years ago, I decided to keep the Thanksgiving menu where it was and change things up for Christmas. I came across an Eggnog Pumpkin Pie recipe on The Gracious Wife that formed the inspiration for this pie. In particular, I loved the idea of the streusel topping and the textural contrast that brings to the pie. While The Gracious Wife shifted away from the streusel topping in her 2023 update, I think it is integral to the personality of this pie.
Eggnog brings additional richness, sweetness, and holiday spice to the custard, resulting in an even more velvety, creamy texture than a classic pumpkin pie. On its own, it’s delicious—and I’ve even left the streusel off a couple of times at the prompting of my younger son (who is a bit of a pumpkin pie purist). But when you crown that beautiful eggnog pumpkin custard with a spiced pecan streusel, I think it’s magical. The cinnamon and nutmeg reinforce the familiar eggnog spices, while the buttery, crumbly topping and crunchy pecans provide a delightful textural contrast that makes the custard seem even creamier.

As always, I’ve made numerous tweaks to the recipe over the years, but it’s remained pretty consistent for the past couple of years, making this the perfect time to share it with all of you. At our house, we like to serve it with a swirl of whipped cream and a sprinkle of nutmeg. Or, if you’re feeling extra festive and want to amp up the eggnog flavor, perhaps some eggnog whipped cream instead, but more on that next week!

Eggnog Pumpkin Pie
Equipment
Ingredients
Method
- Roll out the pie crust until it is about 1/8-inch thick and about 14-inch diameter. Gently fit it into the pie plate being careful not to stretch the dough. Trim the edges leaving up to a 1-inch overhang. Fold and crimp or flute the edge of the crust to form a decorative border for the pie. Place the prepared crust in the freezer for at least 20 minutes.1 deep dish unbaked pie crust
- Meanwhile, preheat oven to 375°F and butter a piece of foil large enough to fit inside the pie crust. Remove the crust from the freezer and press the foil, butter side down, gently against the surface of the crust. Fill the crust with pie weights, uncooked dry beans or sugar. Bake for 20-25 minutes until the crust edges are lightly golden and the surface has a dry, matte appearance with no shiny or translucent areas. Gently lift the foil and weights out of the crust.
- [Optional] If you'd like some extra insurance against a "soggy bottom", while the crust is baking, whisk the egg white well so it is loose and slightly frothy. Immediately after removing the foil and weights from the crust, gently brush the bottom and sides of the hot crust with the egg white. Return to the oven for 2-5 minutes to set the egg white.1 egg white
- Set crust aside to cool slightly and reduce the oven temperature to 350°F.
- In a large mixing bowl, whisk together the pumpkin puree, eggnog and eggs until thoroughly combined.680 g (2 ¾ cups) pumpkin puree, 360 g (1 ⅖ cups) eggnog, 3 eggs
- Add the brown sugar, salt, cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger and cloves and mix well.150 g (⅔ cup) brown sugar, 6 g (1 tsp) salt, 4 g (1 tsp) cinnamon, 3 g (1 tsp) nutmeg, 1/2 tsp (½ tsp) ginger, 1/4 tsp (¼ tsp) cloves
- Whisk in the melted butter and vanilla. Set aside.28 g (2 tbsp) butter, 15 ml (1 tbsp) vanilla
- In a small bowl, whisk together the brown sugar, flour, salt, cinnamon, and nutmeg until it is uniform in color.110 g (½ cup) brown sugar, 15 g (1 tbsp) flour, 2 g (⅓ tsp) salt, 2 g (½ tsp) cinnamon, 2 g (⅔ tsp) nutmeg
- Add the butter and, using a pastry cutter or fork, cut the butter into the dry ingredients just until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs. Stir in the chopped pecans.28 g (2 tbsp) butter, 56 g (½ cup) pecans
- Pour the pumpkin mixture into the par-baked pie crust. Sprinkle the streusel mixture evenly over the unbaked pie filling.
- Bake the pie for 60-75 minutes or until the edges are puffed and firm and the center has a slight wobble but does not appear liquid. If the crust is getting too dark, you can use a pie shield or foil to protect the edges. To help prevent cracking, turn off the oven and leave the pie inside with the oven door propped slightly open to cool slowly for about an hour before removing from the oven and cooling completely on a wire rack. Store the pie, covered tightly, in the refrigerator.



